Deaf Perspective on Hurricane Irma Interpreters

Man speaking at a podium beside a sign language interpreter
~ By Lee Jackson

Why is it necessary to have interpreters at press conferences?  From my Deaf perspective on Hurricane Irma interpreters, I have read some comments that Deaf people can just read the captions on a live press conference.  Most of the time on live TV, there is no captioning.  If there is captioning, it’s not full or clear.  There are always errors in spelling, or the captioner misunderstands what is spoken.  When they realize the misunderstanding, they then go back to correct it which disrupts the comprehension and flow.  When there is no power, sometimes they rely on “Facebook Live” streaming. Again, that is not captioned, and many times the interpreter is only partially shown or not shown at all!  Either way, the message is not clear, and I can only imagine the Florida Deaf Community’s frustration with getting accurate safety information.  Even through all this frustration with technology, if you look back over the last 100 years, how many Deaf people have died from a natural disaster?  Luckily, it’s usually very few.  Most Deaf people are either lucky or had the common sense to go for shelter or get help.

Marshall Greene: Lifeguard Poses as Sign Language Interpreter

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PHXkhUJWTXM

Report on “Amateur Interpreter”

 

(Watch another report here. See what the Manatee lifeguard is really signing. Disclaimer: The term Hearing Impaired which is generally inappropriate and should be replaced with preferred terms such as Deaf or Hard of Hearing.)

My Perspective

My Deaf perspective on Hurricane Irma interpreters, I am still disgusted with both Marshall Greene and Manatee County.  I feel they thought they could get away with using Greene in that manner to get their “15 minutes of fame.”  That was a HORRIBLE way of handling the press conference and a complete disservice to the Deaf community.  Greene should have known better than to get on live TV, but unfortunately he didn’t.  Really, my sister probably would have done the same thing. She can sign the alphabet and a few home signs, so she thinks she knows ASL. I can understand Greene was trying to help, but he should have known better. He could have even contacted his Deaf sibling to ask if it was appropriate.  His Deaf sibling would have likely told him “NO!” and encouraged them to hire a certified professional interpreter.

I lay most of the blame on Manatee County because we now know that they have used a professional interpreting agency in the past. Evacuation of interpreters is not a valid excuse.

Sam Harris, Certified Deaf Interpreter (CDI)

Governor Rick Smith had his emergency press conference the last weekend before Hurricane Irma hit the southern region of Florida. Standing beside him was Sam Harris, who is Deaf and a Certified Deaf Interpreter (CDI) (view video here).  Over the weekend, this press conference went viral because of Harris’ interpreting skills.  There were all kinds of mixed feelings from all around the country.  Even rapper Missy Elliot’s tweet said, “Ok for the sign language guy,” and, “I can’t help but watch how he interprets this & with so much sauce.” The Deaf community feels having a CDI on the emergency news conference is important because native signers will get the correct message disseminated by using their animated facial expressions and body language in addition to American Sign Language.  Most certified hearing interpreters do get the correct message across; but as with any language, it is not as fluent as a native sign language user.

Gone ViralDeaf perspective on Hurricane Irma interpreters

Sam Harris is all over social media.  I can understand why some people think Harris went a little too far with his facial expressions (specifically the tongue), but as a Deaf person I am very much used to that. That’s how most Deaf people, particularly from Deaf families or a Deaf school, have expressed themselves their whole lives.  Especially at Gallaudet or RIT, universities with a high Deaf population, the younger generation tends to be more animated with their ASL than older generations.  Harris’ “outlandish” expressions actually show the language itself without even using his hands.

Jimmy Kimmel

From a hearing interpreter or Deaf person’s perspective, I can understand why they are saying that Sam Harris should have insisted it be done differently when he was asked to be on the Jimmy Kimmel show. Even I was impressed, that for the 2nd time, Jimmy had some Deaf awareness on his show. (First time was hearing interpreters in a Sign Language Rap Battle with Wiz Khalifa.)  For this 2nd time with Harris, he took advantage of mocking the Deaf language…but at the same time, it’s comedy.  We all make fun of another language at times.  Why should it be any different with the Deaf language?  Deaf people can be sensitive because most of us have been bullied our whole lives.  Some interpreters, especially Certified Deaf Interpreters, thought that Harris should be educating the hearing world about Deaf culture.  How?  By having another interpreter on the set with them to show how Deaf Interpreting actually works.  Some thought Harris should explain why facial expressions are so important as a crucial part of the language.

Conclusion

The goal of bringing all these events from a Deaf perspective on Hurricane Irma interpreters is to make is clear communication comes in different forms and should be accessible to all in whatever form they best understand.  Sign Language expression and effectiveness to keep people safe during a disaster like Hurricane Irma come before comedy or easy, cheap services.

 

Additional Resources:

Sign Language Interpreting Company Perspective

Jimmy Kimmel Show with Sam Harris

Sign Language Rap Battle with Wiz Khalifa

 

Posted in
shelly-headshot-3-brand.webp

Shelly Tisius (she/her), RID-NIC, MICS5/BEI-Master

Founder, CEO, and ASL Interpreter

I've been leading teams since long before I became a professional interpreter in 2002, and I worked my own way through school, so I know what it means to build something from the ground up. In 2013 I founded MT & Associates, now Handled. ASL Interpreting, and today I lead how we work, so every detail is handled for our clients.

Categories

Tablet showing an online Create Your Calm workshop

The Communication Access Planning Guide

A free starter guide to planning interpreting and captioning for your event, campus, agency, or workplace. Learn how much notice to give, what each service does, and how to book with confidence. Every guide includes a section for your audience, so you get what’s relevant to you.

Blue circular icon of an I love you handshape

Communication access shouldn't be one more thing to figure out.

See how our ASL interpreting, live captioning, and audio description services can support your event, campus, agency, or workplace. Consider it handled.

Shelly Tisius, Founder and CEO

Shelly Tisius (she/her),
RID-NIC, MICS5/BEI-Master

Founder, CEO, and ASL Interpreter

I’ve been leading teams since long before I became a professional interpreter in 2002, and I worked my own way through school, so I know what it means to build something from the ground up. I’ve done every part of this work, and I love it all. In 2013 I founded MT & Associates, now Handled. ASL Interpreting, and today I lead how we work, so every detail is handled for our clients.

Outside of work, I’m a proud military spouse and mom, usually on the go with my kids.

Bryce Buckley, Operations Manager

Bryce Buckley (he/him)

Operations Manager

As a first-generation college student supporting myself through school, I developed a passion for helping others access the resources and support they need. After several years advocating for students and their families in higher education, I now bring that same commitment to my role as Operations Manager at Handled. ASL Interpreting. I am honored to support our mission of serving the Deaf community and helping people feel heard, understood, and connected.

Bryce spends much of his free time crocheting, bowling, at the gym, with friends, and spending time with his partner and chihuahua, Mabel.

Rain Pioquinto, HR and Social Media Specialist

Rain Pioquinto

HR & Social Media Specialist

Rain Pioquinto helps keep day-to-day operations organized, assists with team and office needs, and supports Handled. ASL Interpreting marketing and communications. She enjoys working behind the scenes, keeping things running smoothly, and finding ways to make everyday processes easier for the team.

Outside of work, she loves spending time at home with her family, occasionally tending to her garden, and enjoying a good cup of coffee.

Caleb Miller, Operations Coordinator

Caleb Miller, BEI Basic

Operations Coordinator

Caleb Miller brings over a decade of experience working alongside the Deaf community to his role as Coordinator. As a certified interpreter (BEI - Basic), he loves applying the skills and insights he has gathered over the past 10+ years to ensure smooth, successful language access for everyone.

Outside of the office, Caleb loves spending quality time with his wife, Natalie, and their two dogs, Marnie and Winnie. When he isn't out on the disc golf course, you can usually find him tackling a good home project in his spare time.

Shannon Veneziani, Operations Coordinator

Shannon Veneziani

Operations Coordinator

Shannon Veneziani helps clients and interpreters know what to expect before every assignment. Whether she's confirming where to meet for a class or finding coverage when a schedule changes, she makes sure everyone has the details they need. Before joining the team, Shannon spent a decade in the coffee industry, managing shops and training new managers across several states. That experience sparked a passion for operations and taught her that the best plans leave room for change, and the questions that are easy to overlook are often the most important ones.

Outside of work, Shannon is usually at the gym, with her family or at home with her cavapoo, Willie. And yes, she can still make you a great cup of coffee.

Scroll to Top